← Back to Case Studies
Food ProcessingFrance · BrittanyIndustrial Structures

Why the Frames Kept Cracking: Bending, Not Torsion
Shown by Vibration Amplification

Brittany, France

Welds, brackets and support members kept failing on industrial meat tumblers at a food processing plant in Brittany, France. Every repair added another reinforcement, and the same areas cracked again. Vibration amplification across about 40 machines finally showed why.

The plant runs a large fleet of industrial tumblers used to marinate and process meat products. Over time the maintenance teams saw recurring structural failures on several machines, particularly around welded joints, reinforcement brackets and structural support members.

To keep production running, they repeatedly added reinforcements and repaired the damage, but the same areas continued to crack. The cost was unplanned downtime, rising maintenance spend, repeated interventions and reduced equipment availability. ASE Serem, which maintains the equipment on site, partnered with VibraVizja™ to investigate before any further modifications were made.

What the Study Set Out to Do
  • →Understand why the tumbler structures were failing repeatedly
  • →Visualise the actual movement of the machines during operation
  • →Test whether structural torsion was responsible, as the maintenance teams suspected
  • →Identify the most highly stressed areas of the equipment
  • →Provide recommendations for structural improvement and reinforcement

'Rather than adding reinforcements wherever damage appears, modify the areas proven to see the greatest mechanical stress.'

Step 1: Watching the Whole Fleet Move

A vibration amplification campaign covered approximately 40 tumblers operating in the production area. Measurements focused on the machine feet and floor anchoring points, the main chassis, the reinforcement members, previously repaired or damaged areas, and the interfaces between the frame and the vessel.

The fleet mixed several designs: heavy-duty machines with large reinforced frames, lighter designs with thinner members, and various floor-mounting configurations. No traditional vibration analysis was performed in this phase — the investigation relied only on vibration amplification to see and compare how the structures behave.

Tumbler frame — amplified video, 5–10 Hz band

Step 2: What the Amplified Video Showed

A clear difference appeared between machine designs. Tumblers with large, rigid frames moved relatively little during operation. Machines built on lighter chassis showed much higher displacement amplitudes and dynamic deformation. The amplified videos highlighted:

  • →Structural resonance effects
  • →Significant bending (flexural) movement of the frame
  • →Dynamic deformation concentrated in critical locations
  • →More movement in areas historically affected by cracking and repair

Before the study, the maintenance teams believed torsion was the main cause of the failures. The images showed a different mechanism: the dominant motion was bending, and the areas with the largest bending amplitudes matched the known failure locations closely.

Probable Root Cause

Insufficient stiffness in certain tumbler designs, stress concentrated in specific areas of the frame, and resonance amplifying the mechanical loads — so welds and reinforcement points see repeated flexural loading. Bending, not torsion, is the main driver of fatigue and cracking.

Three Ways to Act on It

Keep adding reinforcements where cracks appear

This is what had been done. Without knowing the loading mechanism, it is trial and error — and the cracks kept returning.

Reinforce against torsion

Based on the initial assumption. The measurements showed torsion was not the dominant mechanism, so this would have addressed the wrong load.

Stiffen the chassis and target the most stressed areas against bending

Matches the observed behaviour and the real failure locations, and can be prioritised on the machines that need it most.

Recommended Action Plan

A detailed report will go to the plant and ASE Serem, with recommendations to reinforce the most highly stressed areas, increase chassis rigidity where required, reduce flexural movement and resonance, improve long-term durability, and prioritise maintenance on the most critical machines.

The Result and Next Steps

The study moved the discussion from assumptions to evidence. The team now has a direct view of how its machines behave in operation, a validated (and corrected) understanding of the loading mechanism, and a basis for deciding where to spend on reinforcement.

The expected benefits for the plant:

  • →Less reliance on trial-and-error reinforcement
  • →Better targeted corrective actions
  • →Fewer recurring repairs
  • →Better structural design decisions
  • →Higher equipment availability
  • →Fewer unplanned production stoppages

Future modifications can now be focused on the areas proven to see the greatest mechanical stress, instead of following the damage from one repair to the next.

What This Case Teaches
  • →Test the assumption. Maintenance experience pointed to torsion; the machines showed bending.
  • →Compare across a fleet. Seeing rigid and light frames side by side showed that stiffness drives the movement.
  • →Failures sit where the motion is. The largest bending amplitudes matched the known crack locations.
  • →Reinforcement works best when it is targeted. Add stiffness where the structure actually flexes.

See Also

Cracks Keep Coming Back?

If the same welds, brackets or frames keep failing in your plant, let's see how the structure actually moves before you add another reinforcement. We run a live measurement while the machine is running — no production stop, no sensors, nothing attached.

Request a Free On-Site Trial